A Race of Whiners and Deniers
Nicholas Kristof gets it right in his NY Times column today, about how hard it is for us white folks in America to admit what enormous advantages we were born with because of the abuses of the ancestors of people who don’t look like us. He is generous to mention my book, in company of superb work by Orlando Patterson, Charles Blow and others.
As I’ve said and written thousands of times, it’s not about all of us alive today with paler complexions being made to feel guilty, or other people being given a big check. Instead, it’s about what kind of society we’d like our children and grandchildren to live in. It’s not unlike the flawed but brilliant Founders of our country, who recognized many of the failures and tyranny of the system that nonetheless had created them and in many ways was the envy of all humanity at the time. They nonetheless imagined a yet better future, confronted the failures of the status quo at great personal risk, then invented the kind of government and institutions that they believed could achieve their visions. We have the responsibility in our time to do the same–to recognize the flaws in a system that is still the envy of the world, and be willing to imagine a future that improves upon it, and what resources and mechanisms must be in place for the most creative society in history to build that world. If there is any kind of American exceptionalism, it is our capacity to do that as a diverse and varied single nation.
In the days ahead, the news from Ferguson, Missouri and other places is going to be upsetting. People of similar minds and hearts are going to be in conflict over the decision of the grand jury there–whatever that decision is. Almost certainly, the news is going to be neither a sweeping criminal indictment of the policeman at question, nor an exoneration of the police–or of the young man whose life was lost. No one is going to be satisfied–because we have a become a country where these questions cannot be sorted out in clean or satisfactory ways. How American citizens react to that conclusion is unpredictable, contradictory and worrisome.
No matter what happens, we must ask why do we continue to find ourselves in this paralyzed and tortured place of uncertainty so often, and for reasons we almost always cannot untangle. We must be open to designing a future in which these things no longer are a fact of American life.
If nothing else, back to Kristoff’s column, white people must bring an end to this http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/16/opinion/sunday/when-whites-just-dont-get-it-part-4.html cross-generational behavior of denial regarding the consequences of our ancestors’ racially motivated behavior, and cease–dear god, please cease–the decades of whining whenever we are asked to face reality.
The question you raised at the conclusion of your article is, to me, the core of the issue. Making the reality of this history an essential part of our shared understanding of race relations and required reading for law enforcement and penal administrators and personnel is one step in bridging a cultural information gap that perpetuates continued abuse by the “authorities” and sustains a culture of incarceration in the African-American community. I found your book after working on a travel destination article on the coke ovens and coal mines of Dade county Georgia. When it became evident how those mining operations were sustained the sites visited suddenly became charged with a spiritual presence not unlike that encountered if visiting the “arbeitschlage” of the third reich. What are the real time measures in place to accomplish reconciliation in the face of this injustice?
Would enjoy a panel, that included you, Gilbert King, Nicholas Kristoff, Toni Morrison, perhaps. Not only address the advantage of birth, but elaborate on the parallels of the challenges of civil rights of women and blacks and how far we have come, and yet to go. What are the parallel issues of racism and sexism in America and their aligned history?
I would sign up for that panel in two seconds! Thank you very much.
Let’s include Mr. Tim Wise to that panel.
I had the pleasure of listening to Bob Ingraham this week-end describe Manhattan’s struggle (1787) for human freedom against the slave power of Virginia. He called it his contribution to an ongoing discussion. To know or at least be searching for ones human identify means that we will grapple with the idea of the injustice of slavery as a human phenomenon. Will we meet this challenge ever? Well, at least, we’ll have fun working on it. I frankly cannot imagine, and shudder to think what challenge would follow this one if we work this one out and are looking back to the time several thousands of years ago when we had such ignorance. Huh? 🙂 😉 Will the gods be laughing?